Axial SCX10 kit vs Vaterra Ascender K5 Kit

[darkghost92]

I saw that one, it is only a rtr at the moment, however it has the same wheel base as the unlimited does.

[k7zpj]

Originally Posted by darkghost92

I saw that one, it is only a rtr at the moment, however it has the same wheel base as the unlimited does.

If you want a Power Wagon kit:

Buy the JKU kit
Buy the Power Wagon body set. AX31132
Sell the JKU body, top and cage in the RCC classified section.

If you want a Power Wagon flat bed then also get AX80046

[darkghost92]

Went to the LHS and priced out the Rubicon Unlimited, and got side tracked by the Ascender K5, still torn on which one. Time will tell though. haha
[

[yotapower07]

If we want aftermarket support for the ascender then more and more people need to buy them. What aftermarket company is going to blindly make parts for a vehicle that may or may not sell? As for OD/UD it does not have to be done at the axles. Do it with the trans like the tf2 I believe it is. I personally do not own an ascender so I'm not sure if that's even possible. Probably require a motor forward design with a divorced t-case.

[Pavmentsurfer]

I realize this is an older thread but I thought id add a few observations after making the same decision recently.

The Vattera kit is $325ish depending where you look. You do get a bunch of nice upgrades like the metal trans gears and CMS setup... But its still $325 for a kit.

You can buy an SCX10 dingo for just over $200 after discounts. Add about $25 for the 2 metal transmission gears you need and youve got $100 left to spend in other upgrades before you even reach the price of the Vattera kit. If your smart, you can have an equally upgraded Axial for the same price as the Vattera but enjoy the HUGE aftermarket parts support and stellar reputation.

I like the Vattera and do plan to get one. But for my first truck, I wanted something that was cheap, but still good and had enough parts support that I could learn about all the upgrades at my own pace. The Dingo was too good a deal to pass up. I found a cheap Jeep Cherokee body for it, upgraded the trans gears and threw on a few other extras and I'm still darn close the price of the Vattera kit.

[Bully2RockRomper]

The Vaterra kit is the better kit in my opinion, more clearance and much better steering and articulation.

[waw]

Originally Posted by Pavmentsurfer

I realize this is an older thread but I thought id add a few observations after making the same decision recently.

The Vattera kit is $325ish depending where you look. You do get a bunch of nice upgrades like the metal trans gears and CMS setup... But its still $325 for a kit.

You can buy an SCX10 dingo for just over $200 after discounts. Add about $25 for the 2 metal transmission gears you need and youve got $100 left to spend in other upgrades before you even reach the price of the Vattera kit. If your smart, you can have an equally upgraded Axial for the same price as the Vattera but enjoy the HUGE aftermarket parts support and stellar reputation.

I like the Vattera and do plan to get one. But for my first truck, I wanted something that was cheap, but still good and had enough parts support that I could learn about all the upgrades at my own pace. The Dingo was too good a deal to pass up. I found a cheap Jeep Cherokee body for it, upgraded the trans gears and threw on a few other extras and I'm still darn close the price of the Vattera kit.

true..
but then with different region comes different price range.. here in Indonesia, the SCX10 prices ranges from around $360 to $477 due to USD to IDR rate and those custom "prices" here..

with some secondhand items can be cheap, some upgraded rigs also met with higher price.. the things we have to enjoy here

Originally Posted by sic1to

Scx10 imo is best! I know the ascender comes with cms, steal tranny gears & adjustable wheelbase(which is a great idea with links included to do so) but the almost 1/8 scale body, goofy driveshaft design, no ud/od option & lack of aftermarket support its a obvious decision. Besides thats the fun in anything you built to your liking is to be different not identical! Its like everybody having the same vehicle with option of body, tires/wheels & motor only? The frame/parts is sturdy & well designed. Dont get me wrong I was a huge fan of the K5 body(& something different) for sure but when I got mine it was larger than I expected. Sold it got another scx.... Lets be honest its designed from the proven platform of a scx with some efforts to improve here & there with minimum success

I've read somewhere, even the SCX10 is not a true 1/10th scale.. someone posted a data sheet a comparison between the 1:1 scale with the measurement he did on the SCX10, it's between the 1/8th and 1/9th scale.. CMIIW