I'm a believer in you get what you pay for.
Me too.
A portion of the boxes we had in the install bay. :ror:
Big difference is whether you're earning a living with the tools or working on your own crap at home.
I was a big Craftsman buyer until they started shipping production to China and charging the same prices as the American made products. The quality of steel isn't as good, the chrome isn't as nice, and you can see visible changes to the same product to accommodate the weaker materials used. Wrench heads (both box and open) are larger on the Chinese Craftsman stuff.
Specialty tools it's a no-brainer. Snap-On wins. I have Snap-On tools that just aren't made by other companies. Snap-On's ratcheting screwdrivers are awesome. I have three, with various lengths of interchangeable shafts. Even have a shaft for 1/4" sockets that is a huge time-saver in the 12V world.
My large red box is from Harbor Freight. $700 for the roller, $200 for lockers, and $275 or so in the hutch. Can't beat it for a home garage.
Regarding lifetime warranties: Craftsman build their name on the fact that they were American-made tools with lifetime warranties. The problem is that now they're selling Chinese tools with that same lifetime warranty. If you manage to break your USA wrench you're going to get a Chinese replacement with a lobster claw on the open end. I have two ratchets from Crafsman. Exact same except one is made in USA and the other is from overseas. You can feel a difference in the two. The USA model is smoother. Even my wife can tell the difference.
Another problem with Craftsman is that they're trying to sell Chinese tools at the previous American-made prices. By selling Chinese tools they're effectively competing against Harbor Freight. Harbor Freight actually has some nice tools for the average guy. Their impact sockets are good quality and have a lifetime warranty. I've warrantied a dead-blow that I had for YEARS with them. Let a guy borrow it on the trail and he beat the face into oblivion. Went in to replace it and there wasn't an issue. "Go get one off the shelf."
Lowe's also has some nice Taiwanese tools in their Kobalt lineup. I'd take the Taiwanese Kobalt stuff over the Chinese Craftsman.
Snap-On's ratchets can't be beat. I have Craftsman's top of the line 84-tooth ratchets and while they're a better feeling ratchet than anything else Craftsman offers, the Snap-On stuff is so much nicer/smoother in operation.
My pliers are Knipex (German) and my screwdrivers are Wiha and Wera with some Craftsman Pro (bought on clearance) thrown in.
I'm not brand specific. I caught the Knipex stuff on sale at Lowe's, got the Wera stuff on sale, and shop around to get good deals on the Snap-On stuff unless I need something off the truck.
Our Snap-On guy showed up late on a Saturday night to replace a tool. His normal day to the shop was Friday. He came on Friday, tool broke Saturday, called him to let him know, and he just showed up. :lol: We had duplicates of that tool. :lol:
In a professional environment, I'd go with truck brands. Out of all of them, Snap-On is the best I've seen.