Duuuuuude, the problem with debates in forms like the internet and why these debates fail is we all act big online. I don't know you, you don't know me theory. So debating online fails everytime that I've attempted.
I would only see this debate as a failure if absolutely nothing productive came out of it and only one side was voiced.
Has something productive come out of it? Sure. I can't speak for everyone, but I've gathered some more points to ponder.
Has it been one sided? Kind of, and that is a bit dissapointing to me. From what I can tell, and maybe I missed something obvious, but so far the only ones that have contributed have been the non-believers, fence sitters, and a few that feel they don't need to defend their beliefs. There's nothing wrong with those, I'm still holding out for the religiously faithful to voice an intelligent opinion on the matter.
It also has no definite end, unless it were to be completely deleted from the database. If it has no end, there is no winner. It can't fail if its not over.
Zietgeist is good to see...there's others. Though I've seen a few very compelling Intelligent Design movies. Want to wrap your head around something read books by Sam Harris very good author at getting some sensitive ideas across in a still light manner. Or dive deep into the pain of comprehension with Richard Dawkins.
Ah, Richard Dawkins. Seen bits and clips of him before. Interesting stuff.
I'm flip flopping my reading material from one side to the other and all points in between.
I've tried reading the Old Testament several times (I own 6 for some reason...), but the language leaves me behind. I need to keep finding a version that I can keep up with.
The last book I finished was "God Is Not Great", which was a really good athiest based book, and currently I'm in the middle of "How to Know God" which looks at God from a scientific and phsycological perspective. Its also very good.
I think I might try Dianetics next if I can find it out here, though I'm pretty sure its going to have to come from eBay...lol